The impact of jury service on Scottish jurors' health and well-being

Emma Welsh, Noelle Robertson, Lana Ireland, Graham Davies

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

Abstract

Research by Robertson, Davies and Nettleingham (2009) suggested a minority of jurors in English and Welsh courts experience significant short- and longer-term distress from undertaking jury service. This study extended the research to jurors in Scottish trials, with their distinct conventions and procedures. Jurors completed web-based questionnaires measuring juror distress, trauma symptoms, and personal resilience. Results replicated those from England and Wales, showing that some Scottish jurors also experience deterioration in physical and psychological well-being, with female jurors, those sitting in longer trials, and dealing with crimes against the person, being most affected. Trait resilience did not mitigate such effects.
Original languageEnglish
Number of pages14
JournalThe Howard Journal of Crime and Justice
Early online date11 Dec 2019
DOIs
Publication statusE-pub ahead of print - 11 Dec 2019

Fingerprint

resilience
well-being
health
trauma
experience
minority
offense
human being
questionnaire

Keywords

  • juries
  • Scottish incidence
  • stress
  • trauma

Cite this

Welsh, E., Robertson, N., Ireland, L., & Davies, G. (2019). The impact of jury service on Scottish jurors' health and well-being. The Howard Journal of Crime and Justice. https://doi.org/10.1111/hojo.12346
Welsh, Emma ; Robertson, Noelle ; Ireland, Lana ; Davies, Graham. / The impact of jury service on Scottish jurors' health and well-being. In: The Howard Journal of Crime and Justice. 2019.
@article{419d479a9944467f998fbfdb10960869,
title = "The impact of jury service on Scottish jurors' health and well-being",
abstract = "Research by Robertson, Davies and Nettleingham (2009) suggested a minority of jurors in English and Welsh courts experience significant short- and longer-term distress from undertaking jury service. This study extended the research to jurors in Scottish trials, with their distinct conventions and procedures. Jurors completed web-based questionnaires measuring juror distress, trauma symptoms, and personal resilience. Results replicated those from England and Wales, showing that some Scottish jurors also experience deterioration in physical and psychological well-being, with female jurors, those sitting in longer trials, and dealing with crimes against the person, being most affected. Trait resilience did not mitigate such effects.",
keywords = "juries, Scottish incidence, stress, trauma",
author = "Emma Welsh and Noelle Robertson and Lana Ireland and Graham Davies",
note = "Acceptance from webpage AAM req'd 30/10/19 ET; author confirmed version 13/12/19 DC - AAM: 24m embargo",
year = "2019",
month = "12",
day = "11",
doi = "10.1111/hojo.12346",
language = "English",

}

Welsh, E, Robertson, N, Ireland, L & Davies, G 2019, 'The impact of jury service on Scottish jurors' health and well-being', The Howard Journal of Crime and Justice. https://doi.org/10.1111/hojo.12346

The impact of jury service on Scottish jurors' health and well-being. / Welsh, Emma; Robertson, Noelle; Ireland, Lana; Davies, Graham.

In: The Howard Journal of Crime and Justice, 11.12.2019.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

TY - JOUR

T1 - The impact of jury service on Scottish jurors' health and well-being

AU - Welsh, Emma

AU - Robertson, Noelle

AU - Ireland, Lana

AU - Davies, Graham

N1 - Acceptance from webpage AAM req'd 30/10/19 ET; author confirmed version 13/12/19 DC - AAM: 24m embargo

PY - 2019/12/11

Y1 - 2019/12/11

N2 - Research by Robertson, Davies and Nettleingham (2009) suggested a minority of jurors in English and Welsh courts experience significant short- and longer-term distress from undertaking jury service. This study extended the research to jurors in Scottish trials, with their distinct conventions and procedures. Jurors completed web-based questionnaires measuring juror distress, trauma symptoms, and personal resilience. Results replicated those from England and Wales, showing that some Scottish jurors also experience deterioration in physical and psychological well-being, with female jurors, those sitting in longer trials, and dealing with crimes against the person, being most affected. Trait resilience did not mitigate such effects.

AB - Research by Robertson, Davies and Nettleingham (2009) suggested a minority of jurors in English and Welsh courts experience significant short- and longer-term distress from undertaking jury service. This study extended the research to jurors in Scottish trials, with their distinct conventions and procedures. Jurors completed web-based questionnaires measuring juror distress, trauma symptoms, and personal resilience. Results replicated those from England and Wales, showing that some Scottish jurors also experience deterioration in physical and psychological well-being, with female jurors, those sitting in longer trials, and dealing with crimes against the person, being most affected. Trait resilience did not mitigate such effects.

KW - juries

KW - Scottish incidence

KW - stress

KW - trauma

U2 - 10.1111/hojo.12346

DO - 10.1111/hojo.12346

M3 - Article

ER -

Welsh E, Robertson N, Ireland L, Davies G. The impact of jury service on Scottish jurors' health and well-being. The Howard Journal of Crime and Justice. 2019 Dec 11. https://doi.org/10.1111/hojo.12346