Exploring differences between TTO and DCE in the valuation of health states

Angela Robinson, Anne E. Spencer, Jose Luis Pinto Prades, Judith A. Covey

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

38 Downloads (Pure)

Abstract

There is recent interest in using Discrete Choice Experiments (DCEs) to derive health state utility values and results can differ from Time Trade Off (TTO). Clearly DCE is 'choice-based' whereas TTO is generally considered to be a 'matching' task. We explore whether procedural adaptations to the TTO -which make the method more closely resemble a DCE -makes TTO and choice converge. In particular, we test whether making the matching procedure in TTO less 'transparent' to the respondent reduces disparities between TTO and DCE. We designed an interactive survey that was hosted on the internet and 2022 interviews were achieved in the UK in a representative sample of the population. We found a marked divergence between TTO and DCE, but this was not related to the 'transparency' of the TTO procedure. We conclude that a difference in the error structure between TTO and choice and that factors other than differences in utility are affecting choices is driving the divergence. The latter has fundamental implications for the way choice data are analysed and interpreted.
Original languageEnglish
Pages (from-to)273-284
Number of pages12
JournalMedical Decision Making
Volume37
Issue number3
Early online date19 Sep 2016
DOIs
Publication statusPublished - 1 Apr 2017

Fingerprint

Health
Internet
Interviews
Population
Surveys and Questionnaires

Keywords

  • health economics
  • health states

Cite this

Robinson, A., Spencer, A. E., Pinto Prades, J. L., & Covey, J. A. (2017). Exploring differences between TTO and DCE in the valuation of health states. Medical Decision Making, 37(3), 273-284. https://doi.org/10.1177/0272989X16668343
Robinson, Angela ; Spencer, Anne E. ; Pinto Prades, Jose Luis ; Covey, Judith A. / Exploring differences between TTO and DCE in the valuation of health states. In: Medical Decision Making. 2017 ; Vol. 37, No. 3. pp. 273-284.
@article{cfbe6d2d4ad04470970c95cf6386279c,
title = "Exploring differences between TTO and DCE in the valuation of health states",
abstract = "There is recent interest in using Discrete Choice Experiments (DCEs) to derive health state utility values and results can differ from Time Trade Off (TTO). Clearly DCE is 'choice-based' whereas TTO is generally considered to be a 'matching' task. We explore whether procedural adaptations to the TTO -which make the method more closely resemble a DCE -makes TTO and choice converge. In particular, we test whether making the matching procedure in TTO less 'transparent' to the respondent reduces disparities between TTO and DCE. We designed an interactive survey that was hosted on the internet and 2022 interviews were achieved in the UK in a representative sample of the population. We found a marked divergence between TTO and DCE, but this was not related to the 'transparency' of the TTO procedure. We conclude that a difference in the error structure between TTO and choice and that factors other than differences in utility are affecting choices is driving the divergence. The latter has fundamental implications for the way choice data are analysed and interpreted.",
keywords = "health economics, health states",
author = "Angela Robinson and Spencer, {Anne E.} and {Pinto Prades}, {Jose Luis} and Covey, {Judith A.}",
note = "Accepted: 26-7-16 (from webpage) Online pub: 19-9-16 AAM: uploaded 22-11-16; no embargo, SAGE journal",
year = "2017",
month = "4",
day = "1",
doi = "10.1177/0272989X16668343",
language = "English",
volume = "37",
pages = "273--284",
journal = "Medical Decision Making",
issn = "0272-989X",
publisher = "SAGE Publications",
number = "3",

}

Robinson, A, Spencer, AE, Pinto Prades, JL & Covey, JA 2017, 'Exploring differences between TTO and DCE in the valuation of health states', Medical Decision Making, vol. 37, no. 3, pp. 273-284. https://doi.org/10.1177/0272989X16668343

Exploring differences between TTO and DCE in the valuation of health states. / Robinson, Angela; Spencer, Anne E.; Pinto Prades, Jose Luis; Covey, Judith A.

In: Medical Decision Making, Vol. 37, No. 3, 01.04.2017, p. 273-284.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

TY - JOUR

T1 - Exploring differences between TTO and DCE in the valuation of health states

AU - Robinson, Angela

AU - Spencer, Anne E.

AU - Pinto Prades, Jose Luis

AU - Covey, Judith A.

N1 - Accepted: 26-7-16 (from webpage) Online pub: 19-9-16 AAM: uploaded 22-11-16; no embargo, SAGE journal

PY - 2017/4/1

Y1 - 2017/4/1

N2 - There is recent interest in using Discrete Choice Experiments (DCEs) to derive health state utility values and results can differ from Time Trade Off (TTO). Clearly DCE is 'choice-based' whereas TTO is generally considered to be a 'matching' task. We explore whether procedural adaptations to the TTO -which make the method more closely resemble a DCE -makes TTO and choice converge. In particular, we test whether making the matching procedure in TTO less 'transparent' to the respondent reduces disparities between TTO and DCE. We designed an interactive survey that was hosted on the internet and 2022 interviews were achieved in the UK in a representative sample of the population. We found a marked divergence between TTO and DCE, but this was not related to the 'transparency' of the TTO procedure. We conclude that a difference in the error structure between TTO and choice and that factors other than differences in utility are affecting choices is driving the divergence. The latter has fundamental implications for the way choice data are analysed and interpreted.

AB - There is recent interest in using Discrete Choice Experiments (DCEs) to derive health state utility values and results can differ from Time Trade Off (TTO). Clearly DCE is 'choice-based' whereas TTO is generally considered to be a 'matching' task. We explore whether procedural adaptations to the TTO -which make the method more closely resemble a DCE -makes TTO and choice converge. In particular, we test whether making the matching procedure in TTO less 'transparent' to the respondent reduces disparities between TTO and DCE. We designed an interactive survey that was hosted on the internet and 2022 interviews were achieved in the UK in a representative sample of the population. We found a marked divergence between TTO and DCE, but this was not related to the 'transparency' of the TTO procedure. We conclude that a difference in the error structure between TTO and choice and that factors other than differences in utility are affecting choices is driving the divergence. The latter has fundamental implications for the way choice data are analysed and interpreted.

KW - health economics

KW - health states

U2 - 10.1177/0272989X16668343

DO - 10.1177/0272989X16668343

M3 - Article

VL - 37

SP - 273

EP - 284

JO - Medical Decision Making

JF - Medical Decision Making

SN - 0272-989X

IS - 3

ER -