Experts: The Politics of Evidence and Expertise in Democratic Innovation

Ruth Lightbody, Jennifer J. Roberts

Research output: Chapter in Book/Report/Conference proceedingChapter (peer-reviewed)

Abstract

Experts can play a number of roles in democratic innovations. However, there is disagreement between deliberative democrats about whether or not experts should be involved at all. Should the citizens’ deliberations - or their decisions - be divorced from technical expertise? Is this possible - given that expertise shapes the information about a topic that is presented in the public domain, and attended to by policy makers? Or is expertise crucial for defining the scope and relevance of the deliberative or participatory process? In any case, who defines expertise, and what constitutes evidence? Who decides who governs democratic innovations, who provides evidence and perspectives to participants, and what is the best way for this information to be delivered, and digested? This chapter explores some of these issues before outlining some of the key practical and normative issues around involving experts in democratic innovations.
Original languageEnglish
Title of host publicationThe Handbook of Democratic Innovation and Governance
EditorsStephen Elstub, Oliver Escobar
Place of PublicationCheltenham
PublisherEdward Elgar Publishing
Chapter15
Number of pages12
ISBN (Electronic)9781786433862
ISBN (Print)9781786433855
Publication statusAccepted/In press - 5 Dec 2019

Fingerprint

expertise
expert
innovation
politics
evidence
deliberation
citizen

Keywords

  • experts
  • democratic innovations
  • decision making

Cite this

Lightbody, R., & Roberts, J. J. (Accepted/In press). Experts: The Politics of Evidence and Expertise in Democratic Innovation. In S. Elstub, & O. Escobar (Eds.), The Handbook of Democratic Innovation and Governance Cheltenham: Edward Elgar Publishing .
Lightbody, Ruth ; Roberts, Jennifer J. . / Experts: The Politics of Evidence and Expertise in Democratic Innovation. The Handbook of Democratic Innovation and Governance. editor / Stephen Elstub ; Oliver Escobar. Cheltenham : Edward Elgar Publishing , 2019.
@inbook{09283ab56ef34621b734ec016dd36c22,
title = "Experts: The Politics of Evidence and Expertise in Democratic Innovation",
abstract = "Experts can play a number of roles in democratic innovations. However, there is disagreement between deliberative democrats about whether or not experts should be involved at all. Should the citizens’ deliberations - or their decisions - be divorced from technical expertise? Is this possible - given that expertise shapes the information about a topic that is presented in the public domain, and attended to by policy makers? Or is expertise crucial for defining the scope and relevance of the deliberative or participatory process? In any case, who defines expertise, and what constitutes evidence? Who decides who governs democratic innovations, who provides evidence and perspectives to participants, and what is the best way for this information to be delivered, and digested? This chapter explores some of these issues before outlining some of the key practical and normative issues around involving experts in democratic innovations.",
keywords = "experts, democratic innovations, decision making",
author = "Ruth Lightbody and Roberts, {Jennifer J.}",
year = "2019",
month = "12",
day = "5",
language = "English",
isbn = "9781786433855",
editor = "Stephen Elstub and Escobar, {Oliver }",
booktitle = "The Handbook of Democratic Innovation and Governance",
publisher = "Edward Elgar Publishing",

}

Lightbody, R & Roberts, JJ 2019, Experts: The Politics of Evidence and Expertise in Democratic Innovation. in S Elstub & O Escobar (eds), The Handbook of Democratic Innovation and Governance. Edward Elgar Publishing , Cheltenham.

Experts: The Politics of Evidence and Expertise in Democratic Innovation. / Lightbody, Ruth; Roberts, Jennifer J. .

The Handbook of Democratic Innovation and Governance. ed. / Stephen Elstub; Oliver Escobar. Cheltenham : Edward Elgar Publishing , 2019.

Research output: Chapter in Book/Report/Conference proceedingChapter (peer-reviewed)

TY - CHAP

T1 - Experts: The Politics of Evidence and Expertise in Democratic Innovation

AU - Lightbody, Ruth

AU - Roberts, Jennifer J.

PY - 2019/12/5

Y1 - 2019/12/5

N2 - Experts can play a number of roles in democratic innovations. However, there is disagreement between deliberative democrats about whether or not experts should be involved at all. Should the citizens’ deliberations - or their decisions - be divorced from technical expertise? Is this possible - given that expertise shapes the information about a topic that is presented in the public domain, and attended to by policy makers? Or is expertise crucial for defining the scope and relevance of the deliberative or participatory process? In any case, who defines expertise, and what constitutes evidence? Who decides who governs democratic innovations, who provides evidence and perspectives to participants, and what is the best way for this information to be delivered, and digested? This chapter explores some of these issues before outlining some of the key practical and normative issues around involving experts in democratic innovations.

AB - Experts can play a number of roles in democratic innovations. However, there is disagreement between deliberative democrats about whether or not experts should be involved at all. Should the citizens’ deliberations - or their decisions - be divorced from technical expertise? Is this possible - given that expertise shapes the information about a topic that is presented in the public domain, and attended to by policy makers? Or is expertise crucial for defining the scope and relevance of the deliberative or participatory process? In any case, who defines expertise, and what constitutes evidence? Who decides who governs democratic innovations, who provides evidence and perspectives to participants, and what is the best way for this information to be delivered, and digested? This chapter explores some of these issues before outlining some of the key practical and normative issues around involving experts in democratic innovations.

KW - experts

KW - democratic innovations

KW - decision making

UR - https://www.e-elgar.com/shop/handbook-of-democratic-innovation-and-governance

M3 - Chapter (peer-reviewed)

SN - 9781786433855

BT - The Handbook of Democratic Innovation and Governance

A2 - Elstub, Stephen

A2 - Escobar, Oliver

PB - Edward Elgar Publishing

CY - Cheltenham

ER -

Lightbody R, Roberts JJ. Experts: The Politics of Evidence and Expertise in Democratic Innovation. In Elstub S, Escobar O, editors, The Handbook of Democratic Innovation and Governance. Cheltenham: Edward Elgar Publishing . 2019