Assisted suicide and the killing of people? Maybe. Physician-assisted suicide and the killing of patients? No: the rejection of Shaw's new perspective on euthanasia

Hugh V. McLachlan

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

Abstract

David Shaw presents a new argument to support the old claim that there is not a significant moral difference between killing and letting die and, by implication, between active and passive euthanasia. He concludes that doctors should not make a distinction between them. However, whether or not killing and letting die are morally equivalent is not as important a question as he suggests. One can justify legal distinctions on non-moral grounds. One might oppose physician-assisted suicide and active euthanasia when performed by doctors on patients whether or not one is in favour of the legalisation of assisted suicide and active euthanasia.

Original languageEnglish
Pages (from-to)306-309
Number of pages4
JournalJournal of Medical Ethics
Volume36
Issue number5
DOIs
Publication statusPublished - 1 Jan 2010

Fingerprint

Active Euthanasia
Assisted Suicide
assisted suicide
Euthanasia
euthanasia
physician
Passive Euthanasia
legalization
Rejection (Psychology)
Killing
Physician-assisted Suicide
Suicide
Rejection
George Shaw
Doctors

Keywords

  • medical ethics
  • euthanasia

Cite this

@article{287ee1ad0a7b48d4b7151f1ba948d1e1,
title = "Assisted suicide and the killing of people? Maybe. Physician-assisted suicide and the killing of patients? No: the rejection of Shaw's new perspective on euthanasia",
abstract = "David Shaw presents a new argument to support the old claim that there is not a significant moral difference between killing and letting die and, by implication, between active and passive euthanasia. He concludes that doctors should not make a distinction between them. However, whether or not killing and letting die are morally equivalent is not as important a question as he suggests. One can justify legal distinctions on non-moral grounds. One might oppose physician-assisted suicide and active euthanasia when performed by doctors on patients whether or not one is in favour of the legalisation of assisted suicide and active euthanasia.",
keywords = "medical ethics, euthanasia",
author = "McLachlan, {Hugh V.}",
note = "<p>Originally published in: Journal of Medical Ethics (2010), 36 (5), pp.306-309.</p>",
year = "2010",
month = "1",
day = "1",
doi = "10.1136/jme.2009.033118",
language = "English",
volume = "36",
pages = "306--309",
journal = "Journal of Medical Ethics",
issn = "0306-6800",
publisher = "BMJ Publishing Group",
number = "5",

}

TY - JOUR

T1 - Assisted suicide and the killing of people? Maybe. Physician-assisted suicide and the killing of patients? No: the rejection of Shaw's new perspective on euthanasia

AU - McLachlan, Hugh V.

N1 - <p>Originally published in: Journal of Medical Ethics (2010), 36 (5), pp.306-309.</p>

PY - 2010/1/1

Y1 - 2010/1/1

N2 - David Shaw presents a new argument to support the old claim that there is not a significant moral difference between killing and letting die and, by implication, between active and passive euthanasia. He concludes that doctors should not make a distinction between them. However, whether or not killing and letting die are morally equivalent is not as important a question as he suggests. One can justify legal distinctions on non-moral grounds. One might oppose physician-assisted suicide and active euthanasia when performed by doctors on patients whether or not one is in favour of the legalisation of assisted suicide and active euthanasia.

AB - David Shaw presents a new argument to support the old claim that there is not a significant moral difference between killing and letting die and, by implication, between active and passive euthanasia. He concludes that doctors should not make a distinction between them. However, whether or not killing and letting die are morally equivalent is not as important a question as he suggests. One can justify legal distinctions on non-moral grounds. One might oppose physician-assisted suicide and active euthanasia when performed by doctors on patients whether or not one is in favour of the legalisation of assisted suicide and active euthanasia.

KW - medical ethics

KW - euthanasia

U2 - 10.1136/jme.2009.033118

DO - 10.1136/jme.2009.033118

M3 - Article

VL - 36

SP - 306

EP - 309

JO - Journal of Medical Ethics

JF - Journal of Medical Ethics

SN - 0306-6800

IS - 5

ER -