Adverse events and safety issues associated with physical activity and exercise for adults with osteoporosis and osteopaenia: a systematic review of observational studies and an updated review of interventional studies

Setor K. Kunutsor, Sarah Leyland, Dawn A Skelton, Laura James, Matthew Cox, Nicola Gibbons, Julie Whitney, Emma M. Clark

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

330 Downloads (Pure)

Abstract

Purpose: We aimed to conduct a systematic review to identify any adverse effects of physical activity and/or exercise for adults with osteoporosis and osteopaenia. We synthesised the evidence from observational studies and grey literature, and updated the evidence from three previously published systematic reviews of interventional studies (RCTs) of exercise for adults with osteoporosis, osteopaenia and falls risk.
Methods: We searched MEDLINE, EMBASE, CINAHL, Web of Science, grey literature and reference lists of relevant studies from inception to 27 June 2017. Selection criteria were (1) any observational studies, case reports/studies, and non-randomised controlled trials conducted in patients with osteoporosis or osteopaenia; and (2) in accordance with the criteria used in the 3 previous RCT reviews. Pairs of independent investigators screened and extracted data. Where the data allowed, random effects meta-analysis was undertaken for the evidence updates. A narrative synthesis was conducted for the observational data.
Results: For the observational synthesis, 14 studies out of 1,013 potentially relevant citations were included. The greater majority of studies reported no adverse events, reduced incidence/improvement in adverse events, or no significant change in adverse events after physical activity or exercise. Horseback riding, golfing, and activities that involved spinal flexion (certain yoga moves and sit-ups) were associated with a greater risk of back pain and vertebral compression fractures but these events were rare and presented as case studies, not delivered interventions. For the update of interventional studies, 57 additional studies were identified. Exercise was generally associated with a greater number of minor adverse events including mild muscle and joint pain in the intervention arms (OR ranging from 1.08 to 1.50). Serious adverse events were rare and could not be attributed to the intervention.
Conclusion: Patients with osteoporosis and osteopaenia can safely participate in structured exercise programmes, whether at home or in supervised facilities. There is little reported on adverse events with physical activities. We do not recommend complete avoidance of any physical activities, but consideration of safe technique and adaptations. Future studies on interventions should report adverse events more robustly.
Original languageEnglish
Pages (from-to)155-178
Number of pages24
JournalJournal of Frailty, Sarcopenia and Falls
Volume3
Issue number4
DOIs
Publication statusPublished - 1 Dec 2018

Fingerprint

Osteoporosis
Observational Studies
Exercise
Safety
Literature
Yoga
Compression Fractures
Myalgia
Arthralgia
Back Pain
MEDLINE
Patient Selection
Meta-Analysis
Research Personnel
Incidence

Keywords

  • osteoporosis
  • physical actitvity
  • exercise
  • systematic literature review
  • adverse events
  • fractures
  • pain
  • safety

Cite this

@article{d5eb6e79d95740c2ac4a366a6716ca88,
title = "Adverse events and safety issues associated with physical activity and exercise for adults with osteoporosis and osteopaenia: a systematic review of observational studies and an updated review of interventional studies",
abstract = "Purpose: We aimed to conduct a systematic review to identify any adverse effects of physical activity and/or exercise for adults with osteoporosis and osteopaenia. We synthesised the evidence from observational studies and grey literature, and updated the evidence from three previously published systematic reviews of interventional studies (RCTs) of exercise for adults with osteoporosis, osteopaenia and falls risk.Methods: We searched MEDLINE, EMBASE, CINAHL, Web of Science, grey literature and reference lists of relevant studies from inception to 27 June 2017. Selection criteria were (1) any observational studies, case reports/studies, and non-randomised controlled trials conducted in patients with osteoporosis or osteopaenia; and (2) in accordance with the criteria used in the 3 previous RCT reviews. Pairs of independent investigators screened and extracted data. Where the data allowed, random effects meta-analysis was undertaken for the evidence updates. A narrative synthesis was conducted for the observational data. Results: For the observational synthesis, 14 studies out of 1,013 potentially relevant citations were included. The greater majority of studies reported no adverse events, reduced incidence/improvement in adverse events, or no significant change in adverse events after physical activity or exercise. Horseback riding, golfing, and activities that involved spinal flexion (certain yoga moves and sit-ups) were associated with a greater risk of back pain and vertebral compression fractures but these events were rare and presented as case studies, not delivered interventions. For the update of interventional studies, 57 additional studies were identified. Exercise was generally associated with a greater number of minor adverse events including mild muscle and joint pain in the intervention arms (OR ranging from 1.08 to 1.50). Serious adverse events were rare and could not be attributed to the intervention.Conclusion: Patients with osteoporosis and osteopaenia can safely participate in structured exercise programmes, whether at home or in supervised facilities. There is little reported on adverse events with physical activities. We do not recommend complete avoidance of any physical activities, but consideration of safe technique and adaptations. Future studies on interventions should report adverse events more robustly.",
keywords = "osteoporosis, physical actitvity, exercise, systematic literature review, adverse events, fractures, pain, safety",
author = "Kunutsor, {Setor K.} and Sarah Leyland and Skelton, {Dawn A} and Laura James and Matthew Cox and Nicola Gibbons and Julie Whitney and Clark, {Emma M.}",
note = "Acceptance in SAN",
year = "2018",
month = "12",
day = "1",
doi = "10.22540/JFSF-03-155",
language = "English",
volume = "3",
pages = "155--178",
journal = "Journal of Frailty, Sarcopenia and Falls",
issn = "2459-4148",
publisher = "Hylonome Publications",
number = "4",

}

Adverse events and safety issues associated with physical activity and exercise for adults with osteoporosis and osteopaenia: a systematic review of observational studies and an updated review of interventional studies. / Kunutsor, Setor K. ; Leyland, Sarah; Skelton, Dawn A; James, Laura ; Cox, Matthew; Gibbons, Nicola; Whitney, Julie; Clark, Emma M.

In: Journal of Frailty, Sarcopenia and Falls, Vol. 3, No. 4, 01.12.2018, p. 155-178.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

TY - JOUR

T1 - Adverse events and safety issues associated with physical activity and exercise for adults with osteoporosis and osteopaenia: a systematic review of observational studies and an updated review of interventional studies

AU - Kunutsor, Setor K.

AU - Leyland, Sarah

AU - Skelton, Dawn A

AU - James, Laura

AU - Cox, Matthew

AU - Gibbons, Nicola

AU - Whitney, Julie

AU - Clark, Emma M.

N1 - Acceptance in SAN

PY - 2018/12/1

Y1 - 2018/12/1

N2 - Purpose: We aimed to conduct a systematic review to identify any adverse effects of physical activity and/or exercise for adults with osteoporosis and osteopaenia. We synthesised the evidence from observational studies and grey literature, and updated the evidence from three previously published systematic reviews of interventional studies (RCTs) of exercise for adults with osteoporosis, osteopaenia and falls risk.Methods: We searched MEDLINE, EMBASE, CINAHL, Web of Science, grey literature and reference lists of relevant studies from inception to 27 June 2017. Selection criteria were (1) any observational studies, case reports/studies, and non-randomised controlled trials conducted in patients with osteoporosis or osteopaenia; and (2) in accordance with the criteria used in the 3 previous RCT reviews. Pairs of independent investigators screened and extracted data. Where the data allowed, random effects meta-analysis was undertaken for the evidence updates. A narrative synthesis was conducted for the observational data. Results: For the observational synthesis, 14 studies out of 1,013 potentially relevant citations were included. The greater majority of studies reported no adverse events, reduced incidence/improvement in adverse events, or no significant change in adverse events after physical activity or exercise. Horseback riding, golfing, and activities that involved spinal flexion (certain yoga moves and sit-ups) were associated with a greater risk of back pain and vertebral compression fractures but these events were rare and presented as case studies, not delivered interventions. For the update of interventional studies, 57 additional studies were identified. Exercise was generally associated with a greater number of minor adverse events including mild muscle and joint pain in the intervention arms (OR ranging from 1.08 to 1.50). Serious adverse events were rare and could not be attributed to the intervention.Conclusion: Patients with osteoporosis and osteopaenia can safely participate in structured exercise programmes, whether at home or in supervised facilities. There is little reported on adverse events with physical activities. We do not recommend complete avoidance of any physical activities, but consideration of safe technique and adaptations. Future studies on interventions should report adverse events more robustly.

AB - Purpose: We aimed to conduct a systematic review to identify any adverse effects of physical activity and/or exercise for adults with osteoporosis and osteopaenia. We synthesised the evidence from observational studies and grey literature, and updated the evidence from three previously published systematic reviews of interventional studies (RCTs) of exercise for adults with osteoporosis, osteopaenia and falls risk.Methods: We searched MEDLINE, EMBASE, CINAHL, Web of Science, grey literature and reference lists of relevant studies from inception to 27 June 2017. Selection criteria were (1) any observational studies, case reports/studies, and non-randomised controlled trials conducted in patients with osteoporosis or osteopaenia; and (2) in accordance with the criteria used in the 3 previous RCT reviews. Pairs of independent investigators screened and extracted data. Where the data allowed, random effects meta-analysis was undertaken for the evidence updates. A narrative synthesis was conducted for the observational data. Results: For the observational synthesis, 14 studies out of 1,013 potentially relevant citations were included. The greater majority of studies reported no adverse events, reduced incidence/improvement in adverse events, or no significant change in adverse events after physical activity or exercise. Horseback riding, golfing, and activities that involved spinal flexion (certain yoga moves and sit-ups) were associated with a greater risk of back pain and vertebral compression fractures but these events were rare and presented as case studies, not delivered interventions. For the update of interventional studies, 57 additional studies were identified. Exercise was generally associated with a greater number of minor adverse events including mild muscle and joint pain in the intervention arms (OR ranging from 1.08 to 1.50). Serious adverse events were rare and could not be attributed to the intervention.Conclusion: Patients with osteoporosis and osteopaenia can safely participate in structured exercise programmes, whether at home or in supervised facilities. There is little reported on adverse events with physical activities. We do not recommend complete avoidance of any physical activities, but consideration of safe technique and adaptations. Future studies on interventions should report adverse events more robustly.

KW - osteoporosis

KW - physical actitvity

KW - exercise

KW - systematic literature review

KW - adverse events

KW - fractures

KW - pain

KW - safety

U2 - 10.22540/JFSF-03-155

DO - 10.22540/JFSF-03-155

M3 - Article

VL - 3

SP - 155

EP - 178

JO - Journal of Frailty, Sarcopenia and Falls

JF - Journal of Frailty, Sarcopenia and Falls

SN - 2459-4148

IS - 4

ER -