Absence of holistic sexual health understandings among men and women in deprived areas of Scotland: qualitative Study

Lisa McDaid, Kate Hunt, Lesley McMillan, Sian Russell, Dona Milne, Rosie Ilett, Karen Lorimer

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

12 Downloads (Pure)

Abstract

Background: There is a growing evidence base for the need for a holistic approach to sexual health improvement, but the challenges for realising this in the ‘real world’ may be harder in some communities than others. We examined sexual health understandings and behaviours among adult men and women in deprived areas of Scotland.
Methods: Thematic analysis, using the constant comparative method, of qualitative, semi-structured in-depth interviews with 19 men and 16 women aged 18-40 years from the most deprived areas of Glasgow, Edinburgh, Dundee, and three Highland towns.
Results: Even though most had been shown images designed to facilitate discussion about sexual consent and verbal/physical abuse, when first asked, participants overwhelmingly equated ‘sexual health’ with the avoidance of sexually transmitted infections (STIs) and pregnancy. Most of the women interviewed went on to locate their accounts of sexual health within a broader, social account of relationships that in an ideal world, in contrast with their everyday lives, were based on respect and freedom from violence. They expressed desires for more positive relationships, based on open communication and trust, choice and freedom from coercion. A few men did accept a broader definition of sexual health, but others actively resisted it and placed the onus to enact choices and freedom from coercion on women rather than men.
Conclusions: In the first UK study to examine understandings of holistic sexual health among adults living in deprived areas, we found a disjuncture between men and women. These findings suggest that, as a society, we are failing to equip people to enhance their own, and others’, sexual health and wellbeing in its broadest sense. New efforts to emphasise the breadth of sexual health are required, but addressing these complex issues, especially where there are negative underlying gender norms to challenge, will require multi-level interventions targeting individual, community and system levels.
Original languageEnglish
JournalBMC Public Health
Volume19
DOIs
Publication statusPublished - 12 Mar 2019

Fingerprint

Holistic Health
Reproductive Health
Scotland
Coercion
Sexually Transmitted Diseases
Violence
Sexual Behavior
Communication
Interviews
Pregnancy

Keywords

  • holistic sexual health
  • wellbeing
  • heterosexual
  • health improvement
  • deprivation
  • relationships
  • coercion
  • inter-personal violence

Cite this

@article{2bb3aa8c05ca4bde9914f2663ff2438e,
title = "Absence of holistic sexual health understandings among men and women in deprived areas of Scotland: qualitative Study",
abstract = "Background: There is a growing evidence base for the need for a holistic approach to sexual health improvement, but the challenges for realising this in the ‘real world’ may be harder in some communities than others. We examined sexual health understandings and behaviours among adult men and women in deprived areas of Scotland.Methods: Thematic analysis, using the constant comparative method, of qualitative, semi-structured in-depth interviews with 19 men and 16 women aged 18-40 years from the most deprived areas of Glasgow, Edinburgh, Dundee, and three Highland towns.Results: Even though most had been shown images designed to facilitate discussion about sexual consent and verbal/physical abuse, when first asked, participants overwhelmingly equated ‘sexual health’ with the avoidance of sexually transmitted infections (STIs) and pregnancy. Most of the women interviewed went on to locate their accounts of sexual health within a broader, social account of relationships that in an ideal world, in contrast with their everyday lives, were based on respect and freedom from violence. They expressed desires for more positive relationships, based on open communication and trust, choice and freedom from coercion. A few men did accept a broader definition of sexual health, but others actively resisted it and placed the onus to enact choices and freedom from coercion on women rather than men.Conclusions: In the first UK study to examine understandings of holistic sexual health among adults living in deprived areas, we found a disjuncture between men and women. These findings suggest that, as a society, we are failing to equip people to enhance their own, and others’, sexual health and wellbeing in its broadest sense. New efforts to emphasise the breadth of sexual health are required, but addressing these complex issues, especially where there are negative underlying gender norms to challenge, will require multi-level interventions targeting individual, community and system levels.",
keywords = "holistic sexual health, wellbeing, heterosexual, health improvement, deprivation, relationships, coercion, inter-personal violence",
author = "Lisa McDaid and Kate Hunt and Lesley McMillan and Sian Russell and Dona Milne and Rosie Ilett and Karen Lorimer",
note = "Acceptance from webpage Funding: CSO",
year = "2019",
month = "3",
day = "12",
doi = "10.1186/s12889-019-6558-y",
language = "English",
volume = "19",
journal = "BMC Public Health",
issn = "1471-2458",
publisher = "BioMed Central Ltd.",

}

Absence of holistic sexual health understandings among men and women in deprived areas of Scotland: qualitative Study. / McDaid, Lisa; Hunt, Kate; McMillan, Lesley; Russell, Sian; Milne, Dona; Ilett, Rosie; Lorimer, Karen.

In: BMC Public Health, Vol. 19, 12.03.2019.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

TY - JOUR

T1 - Absence of holistic sexual health understandings among men and women in deprived areas of Scotland: qualitative Study

AU - McDaid, Lisa

AU - Hunt, Kate

AU - McMillan, Lesley

AU - Russell, Sian

AU - Milne, Dona

AU - Ilett, Rosie

AU - Lorimer, Karen

N1 - Acceptance from webpage Funding: CSO

PY - 2019/3/12

Y1 - 2019/3/12

N2 - Background: There is a growing evidence base for the need for a holistic approach to sexual health improvement, but the challenges for realising this in the ‘real world’ may be harder in some communities than others. We examined sexual health understandings and behaviours among adult men and women in deprived areas of Scotland.Methods: Thematic analysis, using the constant comparative method, of qualitative, semi-structured in-depth interviews with 19 men and 16 women aged 18-40 years from the most deprived areas of Glasgow, Edinburgh, Dundee, and three Highland towns.Results: Even though most had been shown images designed to facilitate discussion about sexual consent and verbal/physical abuse, when first asked, participants overwhelmingly equated ‘sexual health’ with the avoidance of sexually transmitted infections (STIs) and pregnancy. Most of the women interviewed went on to locate their accounts of sexual health within a broader, social account of relationships that in an ideal world, in contrast with their everyday lives, were based on respect and freedom from violence. They expressed desires for more positive relationships, based on open communication and trust, choice and freedom from coercion. A few men did accept a broader definition of sexual health, but others actively resisted it and placed the onus to enact choices and freedom from coercion on women rather than men.Conclusions: In the first UK study to examine understandings of holistic sexual health among adults living in deprived areas, we found a disjuncture between men and women. These findings suggest that, as a society, we are failing to equip people to enhance their own, and others’, sexual health and wellbeing in its broadest sense. New efforts to emphasise the breadth of sexual health are required, but addressing these complex issues, especially where there are negative underlying gender norms to challenge, will require multi-level interventions targeting individual, community and system levels.

AB - Background: There is a growing evidence base for the need for a holistic approach to sexual health improvement, but the challenges for realising this in the ‘real world’ may be harder in some communities than others. We examined sexual health understandings and behaviours among adult men and women in deprived areas of Scotland.Methods: Thematic analysis, using the constant comparative method, of qualitative, semi-structured in-depth interviews with 19 men and 16 women aged 18-40 years from the most deprived areas of Glasgow, Edinburgh, Dundee, and three Highland towns.Results: Even though most had been shown images designed to facilitate discussion about sexual consent and verbal/physical abuse, when first asked, participants overwhelmingly equated ‘sexual health’ with the avoidance of sexually transmitted infections (STIs) and pregnancy. Most of the women interviewed went on to locate their accounts of sexual health within a broader, social account of relationships that in an ideal world, in contrast with their everyday lives, were based on respect and freedom from violence. They expressed desires for more positive relationships, based on open communication and trust, choice and freedom from coercion. A few men did accept a broader definition of sexual health, but others actively resisted it and placed the onus to enact choices and freedom from coercion on women rather than men.Conclusions: In the first UK study to examine understandings of holistic sexual health among adults living in deprived areas, we found a disjuncture between men and women. These findings suggest that, as a society, we are failing to equip people to enhance their own, and others’, sexual health and wellbeing in its broadest sense. New efforts to emphasise the breadth of sexual health are required, but addressing these complex issues, especially where there are negative underlying gender norms to challenge, will require multi-level interventions targeting individual, community and system levels.

KW - holistic sexual health

KW - wellbeing

KW - heterosexual

KW - health improvement

KW - deprivation

KW - relationships

KW - coercion

KW - inter-personal violence

U2 - 10.1186/s12889-019-6558-y

DO - 10.1186/s12889-019-6558-y

M3 - Article

VL - 19

JO - BMC Public Health

JF - BMC Public Health

SN - 1471-2458

ER -